Fire Island Lighthouse

Not a lot of bells and whistles at this hotel, but who needs them? It is a clean, comfortable place to stay in a GREAT part of town. We loved that it was a short walk back after an evening Broadway show. There was loud street noise one night but, despite being an older hotel, I never heard the guests around me. I suspect everyone else who stays here is out for long days and just needs a place to crash and recouperate. I would stay here again. The deli next door has good, fresh takeout options.

We loved our stay here! Big room for NY, convenient location with lots to do and cool vibe at hotel.

I love this property. However, After waiting 30 min for my husband in the lobby from dropping off the car at the parking lot. To go to my room, I saw SEVEN people ask for umbrellas. Two staff would ask “are you guests?” They’d say yes, & an umbrella was handed to them. I checked in, went upstairs to drop my things off quickly. & rushed back down stairs. I went to the same lady giving out umbrellas & was ready to say “yes I’m a guest.” Only for her to say “you should have one IN YOUR ROOM?” As if go back to your room and get it. When EVERY person I saw received one? Regardless if there WAS ONE in my room?! Why WAS I TREATED LIKE THAT?! That’s tasteless & shows a lot of your employees character. However my perception changed when your KIND hostess at the cantina stated there’s no need for reservations & he’d guarantee we’d have a table if we came back down for dinner. We opted elsewhere but came back for drinks. I of course will be back again, but I sincerely hope yall fix that!