LGBT-Friendly Hotels in South Eleuthera

"We LOVED everything! The only thing they could possibly improve on would be room darkening blinds in the bedroom. My husband slept great; I’m a light sleeper."

"Has everything needed for a relaxing and quiet getaway!"

"**Parkay at Sunset - A Perfect Escape!**This was our second stay at Parlay at Sunset, and it was every bit as amazing as the first. The house is perfectly situated with a beach right in the backyard, making it an ideal spot for snorkeling, critter hunting at night, or simply relaxing by the water. The sunsets here are nothing short of magical – the view of the water almost looks like liquid glass.The property is well-equipped with everything you need. The generator is a AWESOME feature, ensuring we never had to worry about power. The house was spotless, and Diana and Charles were incredibly responsive and helpful throughout our stay.It’s conveniently located near a large grocery store in Rock Sound, and a smaller one in Tarpum Bay, so stocking up on essentials is easy. Plus, the dock is a great spot for fresh fish—perfect for cooking up a meal in the fully stocked kitchen, which had everything we needed to cook at home.It’s just a short 30-minute drive to Pascal's, where you can enjoy a swim-up pool bar and a beautiful beach – we visited multiple times during our trip. And definitely don’t miss the stargazing at night – it’s truly mind-blowing!Before you leave, be sure to pick up a straw hat from Stevie in Tarpum Bay—it's a perfect souvenir.The South Side of Eleuthera has so much to offer, and this property is a perfect base to explore it all. Highly recommend! We will be booking again next summer! "

"One of the most beautiful sites and accomodations that anyone can ask for. The services were amazing and there was not one bad experience. The beach is stellar and the pool is magnificent. Absolutely amazing! "

"We stayed at Coconut Cove in Eleuthera from June 11th to the 20th, and I can honestly say it was the best experience of my life in the Bahamas. The home is absolutely beautiful—immaculately maintained, thoughtfully decorated, and incredibly well-equipped with everything you could possibly need and more. From the moment we arrived, it felt like our own private piece of paradise. The attention to detail throughout the house made it clear the owners truly care about their guests’ comfort and experience. If you’re considering a trip to Eleuthera, don’t hesitate—Coconut Cove is where unforgettable memories are made. I can’t wait to return"

"This house has a ton of charm with a very casual feel to it. Small swimming pool was extremely nice for those days of sunning on the decks then cooling off. The Beach was very close with 3 min or less walk. The master King Bed was very comfortable and had its on walkout balcony deck with beautiful views. There was a 2nd bedroom with large bed and bunk above, which would be nice if you had kids. The pictures accurately illustrate the house. The house is very private, which we liked and was perfect for our stay. It was also well appointed with towels, beach gear, TP, trash bags, coffee maker, coffee filters, etc. Jethro “Host” was extremely kind and helpful & responsive with our inquiries, which gave us a peace of mind. We will be staying again. "

"This was an absolutely amazing rental home. The location was perfect: a quick and easy drive into town and an easy walk to the beautiful beach across the street. Eleuthera can feel rural at times and while this property is tucked a bit out of the way and felt quiet and private it was still easy to access. We loved the town of Governor’s Harbor and were really happy to have this location as our base for exploring the southern side of the island. Everything matched the listing accurately and the layout of the house was perfect for our group of 6 friends and couples. Great common space and a really well appointed kitchen that made cooking at home a breeze. That top deck with ocean views was so peaceful and comfortable for morning coffee. Jethro is a hospitality pro, he welcomed us so warmly, took his time showing us the ins and outs of the property, and was happy to give advice about which restaurants to go to and which beaches and excursions to check out per our group’s needs. We took a lot of his advice and were so glad we did!!We all wish we could’ve stayed much longer and are eager to return. Thanks, Jethro!"

"We traveled to this home as two families with young children who typically vacation together. The house was clean modern. The kitchen was incredibly well stocked with every kind of baking dish and pan and cooking utensil you could need. We loved the layout of the property as it provided plenty of space For not only intimate family time but also quiet time if you wanted to read. The children’s loved playing football on the sand in the backyard and were able to catch 52 conch shells right off the rocks in the back yard. My only reason for four stars was due to location. Fortunately, we rented cars for the week and were able to travel the island easily, but the location was quite removed from many restaurants and sightseeing. I would . Fortunately, we rented cars for the week and we’re able to travel the island easily, but the location was quite removed from many restaurants and sightseeing. I would totally go back there again with our family."

"The hotel is situated in an ideal spot between the Atlantic and the Caribbean. The staff was very friendly and helpful."