Search Town of Starkey Hotels

"Staff couldn’t make any local recommendations but room was decent. "

"We stayed at Jefferson room for two nights. Although this room is facing the busy Main Street, we slept soundly and did not hear anything. We were impressed with the roominess of our room. The bathroom was also spacious. I would recommend putting a bar to hang on to when showering for safety. We love the comfort and convenience of this hotel. It is walkable to restaurants and Watkins Glen State Park."

"Loved the place and the remoteness. The water pump wasn't working, but a solution was promptly provided. It wasn't the best situation, but it worked. Also, the second bed appeared to be a mattress pad behind the main bed. We ended up just sharing the bed for the duration of the stay. Would return, but would love those issues/inaccuracies to be fixed."

"Checkin was so smoothly delivered I thought I was doing something wrong! I was messaged a code for the front door and my room door. There was a message regarding sending a deposit via a link in the message, which I inquired could be done in-person. Location wise the venue is a win. Vibe wise it felt like “spending the night in nana’s attic,” which is comfortable and homely. Bed was firm, fridge and microwave provided, all amenities were serviceable. It was easy to explore town, even if I visited...

"Perfect location and wonderful staff"

"What a nice little hotel-perfect for a quiet couple's get-away! Sooo clean & charming decor, very comfortable, and Jeff, our host went above & beyond accommodating for us!! We will definitely come back!!"

"Check-in was seamless, the staff are courteous and our stay was comfortable. "

"The room was older than expected, but very clean and had a cozy, homey feel to it. The beds were comfortable and it was quiet. The location was perfect for exploring the area, and the view of the lake resulted in a gorgeous sunrise."

"The proprietors were very friendly and generous with the facilities, which in turn were pleasant, well-kept, and with plenty of amenities for travellers."

"We only stayed two nights but the staff was helpful and the view of the lake from the property was beautiful."

"Great place to stay for a wine tour weekend.Room was great. Breakfast was great close to falls Michelle was so helpful."

"Looking forward to coming back."

"Wonderful stay! Can't wait to come back. "

"Love everything! Not just the inn itself but walking distance to great restaurants."