Independent hotels in Coney Island, New York

"Staying at Public was a strange experience! The room was comfortable and even though very small (as is the norm in NYC), you could tell a lot of thought had gone into the design and maximising storage and hanging space. The bed was very comfortable and the shower was great. It’s the ‘open plan’ type of bathroom so I wouldn’t be comfortable sharing with someone I’m not in a relationship with! Very little privacy. The weird part is that you pay hundreds of dollars a night to not talk to any...

"Loved our stay great place and always my go too for soho! "

"The hotel is in a great location, and everything else was good, but the lobby is a huge disappointment. I can’t believe how it’s set up. They keep the door open, and today, for example, it was only 28°F (below 0°C). People are constantly coming in and out, so the door stays open more than it’s closed. It’s freezing, almost to the point of cruelty. This isn’t just uncomfortable for guests but also for the workers—it’s inhumane. The front desk staff are forced to wear jackets because it’s so...

"Great place to stay. Small but had everything we needed. Felt safe. Convenient location. "

"Hotel was great, only thing it was hard to adjust the temperature in the room and it was too hot "

"The rooms could use updating but they were clean and in a great area "

"The hotel was quiet and the staff was very friendly."

"Great location if you are focused on Brooklyn and surrounding area. Convenient to restaurants and subway stations and local shops. The hotel has a vibe to it. Our disappointment was with the room. The TV went blank every ten to 15 minutes and took several minutes to turn back on. While we asked for service, it was never fixed so we had 3 days with the inconvenience. We set our room to be cleaned but when we returned after being out all day the room hadn’t be cleaned and no fresh towels...